According to Lincoln Center's new LCT3 project at its slogan, it takes "New Audiences for New Artists." It also takes new critics, hence the establishment of Theater Talk's New Theater Corps in 2005, a way for up-and-coming theater writers and eager new theatergoers to get exposure to the ever-growing theater scene in New York City. Writers for the New Theater Corps are given the opportunity to immerse themselves in the off-off and off-Broadway theater scene, learning and giving back high-quality reviews at the same time. Driven by a passion and love of the arts, the New Theater Corps aims to identify, support, and grow the arts community, one show and one person at a time.
Showing posts with label Jason Fitzgerald. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jason Fitzgerald. Show all posts

Thursday, January 22, 2009

Shadow of Himself

Adapting the Epic of Gilgamesh may seem a task for the gods. But Neal Bell's new play, Shadow of Himself, manages to streamline the classic work—a collection of Sumerian mythology that may be the oldest surviving piece of literature—into a one-act play. The result is both a moving love story and a hard-won lesson on mortality and human limitations, and while Rabbit Hole Ensemble doesn't realize the full scope of Bell's dramatic vision, it gets it right where it counts.

Review by Jason Fitzgerald

In Shadow of Himself, Neal Bell condenses the meandering plot of the Gilgamesh source, but he keeps most of the major events. In the play, a proud half-god named "Gil" befriends a wild man, “NK” (named Enkidu in the original), who has been civilized by an encounter with a prostitute. Together they slay the monstrous Humbaba, but the encounter leads to the death of Enkidu, sending Gil to the underworld and, finally, to an encounter with the truth of his half-human nature. Bell condenses the legend's thematic scope, making it a parable about shedding illusions of immortality and embracing our kinship with the natural world. In the process, he makes he epic relevant to contemporary lives.

There is a risk that audiences of Shadow of Himself will now see the semi-divine Gil as a man with an ego problem, but Bell maintains a sense of the mythic by blending action with narration, and imbuing both with a fatalistic lyricism. These qualities, along with the play's privileging of the natural over the supernormal, make Shadow of Himself a perfect fit for the Rabbit Hole Ensemble, whose mission is to use the human body to create theatrical illusion and effects. Indeed, they prefer to ban all forms of mechanical spectacle (except for lighting design) from the stage. In this production, that means a cast of five that plays all the roles (the actors playing Gil and NK do not double) and creates every setting from the magical "Cedar Forest" to the river that leads to hell.

The aesthetic gamble does not quite pay off. There are too many moments where the sense of magic and myth, necessary for the play to succeed, seems to vanish from the room, leaving behind only a small band of actors trying to put on a play. The chanting chorus is too often silent to build a counterpoint to the main action. The actors vary their physicalities when asked to play monsters or lions, but it's often hard to distinguish one human character from the next. A subplot that Bell has created, about two soldiers who balance their desire to be masculine with their love for each other, suffers the most in this regard.

No wonder the most successful aspect of the production is the homoerotic relationship between Gil and NK. The scene where their physical enmity turns into physical intimacy—"The more I fight you the more I want to fight you"—requires nothing but emotion and stillness. Their separation, and Gil's tremendous grief in losing his friend, answer the earlier scene with a haunting silence. Emphasizing the physical and romantic love of these two figures is Bell's most significant contribution to the epic, and it raises the stakes of Gil's moral journey. In this production, the lessons he learns from his one great love leave the deepest impression on us fellow mortals.

--------------------------------------------------------------
Shadow of Himself (80 minutes, no intermission)
Access Theatre (380 Broadway)
http://www.rabbitholeensemble.com/ ($20 tickets)
Performances thru Jan 31st: Thurs - Sun 8pm

Friday, December 12, 2008

Hillary: A Modern Greek Tragedy with a (Somewhat) Happy Ending

There is a surprising correspondence between celebrity gossip and Greek tragedy: Both break stories down into archetypes and a series of tableaux, and by doing so, they become models for how (or how not) to live our own lives. But gossip makes us feel superior to its subjects, while tragedy makes them our equals, so that their struggles become our own. It is this formula that lets Wendy Weiner’s Hillary: A Modern Greek Tragedy with a (Somewhat) Happy Ending transcend its Saturday Night Live potential to become a surprisingly moving and humanizing retelling of one celebrity’s familiar story.

Photo/Jim Baldassare

Reviewed by Jason Fitzgerald

The simplicity of the show’s setup yields its rewards: The goddesses Athena (war and reason) and Aphrodite (love and passion) are in a terrible feud, and the lives of mortals are their primary battlefield. A young girl named Hillary, whose dreams of being an astronaut have recently shattered, decides to become Athena’s disciple. Aphrodite, spurned, responds by unleashing her own acolyte on Hillary’s bright future: Enter Bill Clinton. The rest is history, or, as the play suggests, cultural myth: “Chelsea Morning” on the radio yields to the governor’s mansion, Jennifer Flowers, the White House, the pastel skirts, the healthcare tome, and, finally, the definition of “is.”

The task of playing the tragic hero falls to Mia Barron, an actress of growing stature on the American stage (The Coast of Utopia, QED, The Pain and the Itch), but unfamiliar enough not to compete with her famous character. Barron is an unlikely Hillary: her sharp features, darting eyes, and strong diction make her performance a bit like Tina Fey’s might be. But she is a smart actress, less concerned with impersonation than with her character’s subtle development from awkward, headstrong girl to steely, voracious adult. Her strongest moment comes after Hillary allows Athena to remove half of her heart, so that cold ambition might replace pain at her husband’s wandering eyes. There’s no immediate change after this cosmic surgery; instead, over the next ten minutes, it becomes clear that her vulnerability has disappeared.

The balance between heart and hardness is the ultimate moral of the story. In the last third of the play, a post-Lewinsky Hillary begs Aphrodite, her former rival, to remove the other half of her heart. Aphrodite sends her to hell (via Newt Gingrich’s back door, of course) to fetch a golden harp, an adventure she barely survives, thanks to Bill’s saxophone, which soothes the three-headed monster Cerberus. Barron’s quiet, intense delivery of Hillary’s response—“Goddamn you, Bill. I will not cry”—brings all the contradictions of Hillary’s broken, armored heart into focus.

Her anagnorisis is to see clearly that her vulnerability and, yes, her love for her imperfect husband, are as much a part of her makeup as her strength and her ambition. The lesson is ours as much as hers, a challenge to any simplistic reading of Ms. Clinton, and a surprising plea for complex sympathy from a play that purports to move in two dimensions. One may wish for the play, which was written in 2006, to include the latest events in Hillary’s story (sequel alert!). Instead, it ends with her declaration, upon joining the Senate: “Whether it be my generation, or the next, we will have a female president.” It is the kind of terribly ironic echo that will likely trail this complex figure—the character and the woman—long after her story is over.

-------------------------------------------
Hillary: A Modern Greek Tragedy with a (Somewhat) Happy Ending (1hr 30 min, no intermission)
The Living Theatre (21 Clinton St)
Tickets (212-868-4444): $20.00
Performances (through 12/20): Sun-Mon 8pm & Wed-Fri, 8pm

Thursday, December 11, 2008

Caligula

To say that Albert Camus’s 1944 play, Caligula, still feels contemporary is to speak poorly of the 21st century. We may have only the terror-riddled, Depression-struggling present of today’s headlines to blame, but who doesn’t at least appreciate the unsettling notion that whatever deity or sense of purpose we might have counted on has abandoned us? Caligula explores the consequences—both seductive and destructive—of giving up and succumbing to the law of arbitrary cruelty. It is to Camus’s credit that his script, in the New York premiere of David Grieg’s taut translation, manages to sizzle despite an inept production by Horizon Theatre Rep.

Photo/Richard Termine

Reviewed by Jason Fitzgerald

Composed in the early days of Hitler’s rise to power (it took five years to be published), Caligula was Camus’s attempt to make sense of the tyrannical cruelty that was casting its shadow over Europe. His model is the mad Roman emperor Caligula, who, Camus surmises, was transformed from a kind and beloved leader to a vicious tyrant in the wake of his beloved sister’s death. Awakened to the arbitrary purpose of the universe—the nihilistic philosophy that is Camus’s legacy—Caligula decides to give his subjects “the gift of meaninglessness.” Years pass as his horror-struck advisors watch their leader pronounce death sentences and even famines on a whim, until they finding themselves tottering on the brink of the same madness.

Thankfully, director Rafael de Mussa (who plays Caligula) avoids a George W. Bush parallel, putting his actors in contemporary dress but leaving the whole production in an unspecified time and place. The Bush comparison wouldn’t fit anyway: the president’s failings come from the vague sense of himself as God’s vessel, while Caligula’s come from the concrete certitude that neither God nor sacred values are worth depending on. David Grieg’s translation makes these motivations clear, remaining faithful to the original while scraping away excess verbiage (he brought a similar economy to his translation of The Bacchae at the Lincoln Center Festival this past summer).

It is unclear, though, why Grieg chose to premiere his new translation with this company of actors. Whether due to youth, inexperience, or weak talent, they bring little urgency or realness to the play. In scene after scene where the emperor’s advisors must respond to his cruelty, the company’s emotions are circumstantial rather than existential, like schoolchildren angry that their principal is loose with the detention slips. De Mussa captures the dark exterior of his antihero, but he fumbles when asked to reveal the pain and confusion that have caused Caligula’s madness. The challenge of the play is to make the audience feel both the terror of the emperor’s subjects and the pity the man himself deserves. This production achieves neither.

By contrast, the simple set design by Peter R. Feuchtwanger—a long table with chairs in front of five perfectly spaced-out columns—suggests a more successful direction. A blazing (fake) fire, sitting atop a pedestal upstage center and the focal point of the symmetrical space, is a correlative to the play’s central question. Does the flame represent God? A faith in humanism? The steady glow of the ego? Or is it simply a stage prop, mocking our futile search for greater meaning? Staring into the fire, one glimpses the promise of the wave of Caligula productions that Horizon Theatre Rep’s may anticipate, especially if the next four years of federal governance are not all we’re depending on them to be.

-------------------------------------------
Caligula (2 hours, no intermission)
Theatre Row: The Kirk Theatre (410 W 42nd Street)
Tickets (212-279-4200): $18.00
Performances (through 12/30): Sun 3pm, Mon & Tues 8pm, Thurs - Fri 8pm

Tuesday, October 28, 2008

Crawl, Fade to White

Crawl, Fade to White, the seventh production of the playwright-run 13P, is as unnerving as it is rewarding. Plots do not fully cohere and characters hold onto their secrets, but it is through the ambiguities of her theatrical world that Sheila Callaghan constructs a landscape of loss more honest than a confession, and more haunting than a trance.

Photo/Jim Baldassare

Reviewed by Jason Fitzgerald

If the ground is bare in October and it’s 90 degrees out, can you still call it a “fall clearance sale?” Dan and Fran, an elderly couple in Sheila Callaghan’s new play Crawl, Fade to White, don’t think so: The play opens with the pair sitting in their home, cutting leaves out of colored construction paper. With autumn gone missing, their crafts hold the spiritual force of a rain dance, filling an absence by force of will. Their small ritual inaugurates a theatrical event that does not so much explore loss as a theme but give it a shape, full of holes that yearn to be unmade.

The plot of Crawl, Fade to White is mostly impressionistic, but loss is its structural core. Dan and Fran mourn the loss of their two children in an unnamed “tragedy.” Their neighbor Louise nurses a broken heart left by her daughter’s father, though they were lovers for barely a year (she was 15) before he fled. For their grown daughter April, who never met her father, his absence remains acute and crippling. In fact, when we first meet her, back from college with her boyfriend Nolan, she acts childishly, trying to steal back a lamp he once touched.

In Anna Kiraly’s evocative set design, beneath the raised stage that represents Dan and Fran’s house there is a line of soil bearing a collection of discarded children’s toys—a visual reminder of each character’s troubled relationship with childhood. Kiraly’s set, combined with Paul Willis’s vivid staging, allows loss to structure the audience’s experience as well. Settings are bounded by pairs of tall white flats, set at right angles and placed on wheels, that adjust for each location but leave the scarred interior of the Ideal Glass Gallery always visible. Scenes are interspersed with the sound of strings, barking, crying, and rainfall, though images of violins, animals, babies, and rainwater are nowhere to be found. The sparsely chosen props—a beach chair in the couple’s yard, a telephone in their living room, a chair in a neighbor’s house—do not suggest a more elaborate location in a realistic world: rather, the locations in question are that bare.

The play is meant to feel disorienting: each short scene (and line of dialogue) feels intentionally, abruptly, unfinished. April refuses to let the lamp out of her sight once she finds it, Dan and Fran claim the young students as replacements for their lost children, Nolan (who faces his own demons) finds healing after a lovemaking scene with Louise—it's not rational, but for souls desperate to fill the gaping voids that define them, emotion and impulse becomes logic. The actors bravely eschew rounded psychologies, letting a mysterious inner logic ground their characters in external will and drive—Jocelyn Kuritsky’s April shakes like an overheated bomb, while Carla Harting’s Louise applies lipstick like an addict taking pills.

The surprising effect of all this ambiguity is to make us pay more attention, to imbue the simplest of actions (a Polaroid camera flash, the wearing of an apron) with dire importance, so that we participate in the play’s vain grasping for any object, action, or memory that can bring clarity and closure. Callaghan’s vision is bleak, but it is also true to the denials, insanities, and backward glances that constitute psychic wounds refusing to scab over.

-------------------------------------------
Crawl, Fade to White (90 minutes, no intermission)
Ideal Glass Gallery (222 East 2nd St)
(212) 352-3101, or http://www.13p.org/ for tickets
Wed-Sat 8pm, through Nov 1st

Monday, October 06, 2008

Woyzeck

Counting Squares’s Woyzeck is a classic case of how a forced directorial concept can diminish a classic play. Joshua Chase Gold tries to make Büchner’s tale into a contemporary American war story, but this classic German anti-hero does not fit his new fatigues.

Reviewed by Jason Fitzgerald
[See also: Cindy Pierre's review]

A young American soldier points a gun at the audience as female voices sing “Amazing Grace.” A Wagnerian mountain crag with a mysterious wooden wheel stands behind him. The soldier exits, and three women dressed in Goth-inspired laces and leather straps strut onto the stage to sing “Boogie Woogie Bugle Boy,” complete with Andrews Sisters choreography. The soldier re-enters with a comrade and begins speaking lines from Georg Büchner’s 1873 poetic tragedy Woyzeck. Each image is memorable in its own right, but . . . what do they have to do with each other?

So begins Counting Squares Theatre’s production of Woyzeck, which, unfortunately, never finds a satisfactory answer for this provocative question. The basic concept, as conceived by director Joshua Chase Gold, is to use Woyzeck (in which a man is brutalized by a faithless world and brutally murders his faithless wife) to tell the story of an American soldier stricken with post-traumatic stress disorder. The three-woman chorus, an invention of Gold’s, are a manifestation of Woyzeck’s growing illness: Only he can see these seductive sirens.

The production is as forced as the concept, and it butchers Woyzeck’s poetic “A fire’s sailing around the sky and a noise coming down like trumpets” by following it with his buddy’s “C’mon, man, they’re calling us!” As for scenes not as easily assimilated to the soldier’s tale, like that of the scalpel-hearted doctor who pays Woyzeck to eat peas for a month, they read as campy, and comic, interludes rather critical signposts on the road to Woyzeck’s self-destruction.

The main character’s insanity—made manifest in visions, drunkenness, and violence— ultimately undermines the production. What has made Woyzeck a lasting dramatic work, and a gateway to modernism, is the vague existentialism of the character’s crisis—he is both pauper and prophet, and his visions of a godless world, derived in part by mistreatment by the bourgeoisie, have a universal resonance. In Gold’s production, this condition is too diagnosed, too easily explained away as a byproduct of military service. Worse, since Büchner offers no symptoms specific to P.T.S.D. in his script, the production must generalize the very condition it aims to politicize, turning the soldier’s condition into madness-writ-large rather than a specific kind of “psychic wound,” as a recent New Yorker article on this very subject describes it.

The set, a pair of paper-maché mountaintops out of Night on Bald Mountain and a bed for the scenes with Woyzeck’s wife, come from another world altogether. They look like neither Iraq nor “Midwest America,” where the program claims the production takes place. If they are meant to conjure the metaphysical yearnings of Büchner’s protagonist, the American soldier in front of them only heightens the disjuncture between play and concept.

The actors win points for commitment, but their performances are necessarily general, as lifelessly energetic as a stump speech. Ryan Nicholoff, as Woyzeck, tries to convince us that choreographed screams, eye rolls, whistling, and stuttering are the sum of his character’s deadly paradigm shift. I wasn’t convinced. And besides, I was too busy watching the chorus, whose tuneful World World II-era harmonies and Andrews Sisters dance moves make the unaccountable interruptions of “Miss Otis Regrets” and “Bye Bye Baby” the most entertaining parts of the evening. If they’d been allowed a cabaret act all to themselves, the evening might have been more cohesive, or at least, unreservedly fun.

——————————————————————
Woyzeck (70 min., no intermission)
Under St. Mark’s (94 St. Mark’s Place)
Tickets: $18-23
Performances: Through 10/29 (Tues & Wed 7pm)

Thursday, September 11, 2008

Elizabeth Rex

The costumes rule the kingdom in Nicu’s Spoon’s production of Elizabeth Rex, remounted for a four-week run at Off-Broadway’s Center Stage. It’s as though the production budget went entirely into costume designer Rien Schlecht’s pockets, and she has used it well, turning a play about power, gender, and performance into a play about clothes, which is to say she found a clarifying outlet for the whirling themes of the late Timothy Findley’s play. Add a pair of virtuosic performers to inhabit the two leads, and all that the rest of the company needs to do—along with the drab, hastily painted set—is stay out of the way.

Reviewed by Jason Fitzgerald

Elizabeth Rex imagines an evening—specifically, February 25th, 1601—when Elizabeth I chooses to wait out the execution of her lover, the treasonous Robert Devereux, in a barn inhabited by Shakespeare’s players. There, amidst the fracas of a company celebrating a performance of Much Ado About Nothing, she meets Ned Lowenscroft: sodomite, diva (he played Beatrice), and slowly fading victim of an unnamed venereal disease. After trading insults and wits, Elizabeth (Stephanie Barton-Farcas) and Lowenscroft (Michael DiGioia) strike a deal—he will teach the queen how to be a woman (and so grieve for Devereux), and she will teach Ned how to be a man (and so face death with dignity). They spend the rest of the play squirming toward their catharses.

Rather than dodge the gay-man-with-AIDS stereotype on which Ned is clearly based— anachronistic to the 17th century and outdated for the 21st—DiGioia reveals its enduring power. He earns the audience’s admiration for committing to the fey but lion-hearted victim who does not so much rage as swat against the dying of the light. Barton-Farcas doesn’t quite share DiGioia’s subtleties, and her preoccupation with the monarch’s accent and clipped tone makes it hard to catch her words, but she commands the stage and, with a glare that threatens to burn the barn down, earns the respect of her subjects on and off the set.

And yet—the production is really about the clothes. After a brief prologue delivered by an aging Will Shakespeare, the evening begins with a rush of gowns, hairpieces, bodices, stockings, tunics, bells, funny hats, and banners hastily removed and tossed about by actors. The unimpressive set, a mix of hastily painted grays, wood-colored wall posts, and chairs and tables that could have come from any theater’s prop closet, only focuses our attention onto the costume design, revealing an added layer to the power struggle between Ned and Elizabeth. That their costumes (the manly crown, the womanly garments) have taken their hearts captive is their power and their tragedy—for Ned, the power to speak freely to the queen and the cruelty of his slow death; for Elizabeth, the power to rule England and the resulting tragedy of sending her “Robin” to the ax.

While the rest of the actors easily shed their outer layers for plain white shirts, the two leads are more hesitant to remove their coverings. It is some time before we see Ned without his make-up (his open sores the only cosmetic he cannot remove), and even longer for Elizabeth to change into a less ostentatious outfit and—a theatrical triumph—to remove her wig. It doesn’t take a queen—or an actor—to empathize with their resistance to let go of surface identities and face the more complicated, and more fragile, truths within.

There’s little to say for the rest of the characters, or for the actors who—competently but not expertly directed—fade into the background with the set. The dying Shakespeare of the play’s outer frame seems more drunk than feeble, leaving a major aspect of Findley’s play—the recovery of the playwright’s memory and the closet-like pain of the secrets he’s kept—mostly unnoticed. Sammy Mena plays Ned’s pet bear with a dedication that underscores the humiliation of the task, especially since playing the creature sans costume makes no sense in a production so otherwise aware of its surfaces. What remains is essentially a two-character drama, a kaleidoscope of colors and fabrics, and a fine introduction to a lesser-known work.

Monday, August 04, 2008

MITF: Love, Incorporated


Reviewed by Jason Fitzgerald

Love, Incorporated
seems to have a point, which is that the scruples-be-damned strategies of the corporate sector have no place in real-life romance. But does Marc Castle (book, music, and lyrics) believe this message? After all, his cookie-cutter love story is calculated, like the best sales pitch, to privilege charm over substance. Given that the Midtown International Theatre Festival has placed the show in its new Commercial Division, giving it extra support for a commercial future, the plan seems to be working. There are no surprises here—Faith, a plain-looking research analyst, scores her dream man after an obligatory makeover, a couple of hours spent scheming (she hires her neighbor and a local actor to create a matchmaking business, Love, Inc., with herself as its only client), and some ballad belting. Clichés are treated like revelations, with lyrics like, “Christmas is the most depressing time of year” and a scene that turns on the line, “There are lots of bumps on the rocky road to perfection.” The evening is buoyed by a jaunty if unoriginal score and a fine performance by the ensemble, particularly Hollis Scarborough, whose finger-snapping slickness as Faith’s assistant (“I’m not your friend. I’m your neighbor.”) provides a touch of edginess that the musical badly needs. However, a faster-paced direction would smooth over the rough spots and fuse some real comic timing into the show. By the time Faith’s two associates are singing about Love, Inc.’s first “success story,” the newly coupled subjects having rejected their business-minded ways, I wondered just what mode of courtship Love, Incorporated was advocating. My discomfort faded as I left the theatre, quietly humming the tunes while plot, lyrics, and character disappeared like a newly printed receipt.

Friday, August 01, 2008

MITF: Love, Flies in the Snuffbox

Reviewed by Jason Fitzgerald

Chekhov dismissed his “vaudevilles,” the short comic plays that comprised the bulk of his dramatic output, as “trivial” and “foolish,” “jokes” without substance. It’s easy to give them the same thrift in production—Chekhov, light and fluffy!—but only at their peril. Although the plays satirize people’s tendency to self-dramatize until they become caricatures of themselves, Chekhov’s style is never simply to belittle. As in the later plays, he underscores his criticisms with empathy, and he colors his comedy with loss and failure. The successful realization of the three Chekhov shorts that make up in Love, Flies in the Snuffbox, all directed and translated by Dustin Condren, depends on the actors’ ability to create, not clowns, but real people who behave like clowns. The Proposal, in which two neighbors can’t stop quarrelling long enough to propose marriage, fares the worst: The characters are reduced to a collection of postures and vocal ticks, and the situation becomes mildly silly rather than uproarious and true. The Bear, in which a widow committed to a life of mourning is seduced by a rustic neighbor, holds up slightly better, thanks to Victoria Levin’s ironic righteousness as the widow and the palpable erotic charge found in the final scene. But the highlight of the evening is Rick Delaney’s textured and pathetic performance in On the Harmful Effects of Tobacco, about a middle-aged man who turns a “lecture for charity” into a helpless cry from a mediocre, emasculated existence. Delaney stammers and stumbles his way through the monologue, screwing up his face and tightening his suit jacket as though holding back screams or tears…or both. He never quite collapses—this pitiable character can’t even have a decent breakdown—but makes us feel embarrassed to laugh at the downfall of an unimportant man. Delaney’s performance fulfills the dual potential of the vaudevilles—proving that Chekhov’s earlier achievements can hold their own, while simultaneously opening a window to the quietly desperate figures (Medvedenko, Gaev, Sonya) of the later masterpieces.